Moving Scam Red Flags: A Checklist Tied to Federal Rules
On this page
Moving scam red flags, checked against federal rules
For interstate moves. Read each line as a question: is this happening to me? Each one says what the federal rule requires, so you can answer from the rule and not from a feeling. Ticks are saved in this browser only.
0 of 33 done
Before you book
Part 375 applies to household goods carriers moving belongings across state lines. A move inside one state falls under that state's rules, which this list does not cover.
49 CFR 375.401(b) requires a written estimate of the total charges, marked binding or non-binding, before a bill of lading is executed. FMCSA's booklet says a verbal quote is not an official estimate. Ask for the written version and wait for it.
375.401(a) requires a physical survey of the goods unless you waive it in writing before loading. The booklet says the survey can be on site or virtual. If you did not choose to waive it, ask for the survey.
375.401(h) requires you and the mover to sign the estimate, and a dated copy goes to you when you sign. 375.401(b) requires it to say which type it is.
375.207(b) requires every advertisement to carry the company name as it appears on its USDOT assignment document and its USDOT number, shown as U.S. DOT No. followed by the number.
FMCSA's consumer page offers the database search. The booklet in Appendix A advises avoiding brokers and movers that are not registered with FMCSA.
Source: FMCSA, Protect Your Move
375.213(a) requires both to come with the written estimate, as a copy or a website link. If you got a link, 375.213(f) requires a signed, dated receipt for it.
375.213(b) lists four documents the mover must hand you before executing the bill of lading: the estimate, notice that tariff sections are available, an arbitration summary and a complaint-handling summary.
375.505(g)(3) says a mover may not require you to sign a blank document. 375.505(h) requires the bill of lading to be signed at least 3 days before loading, with a 3-day period to rescind without penalty.
At pickup
375.503 requires a written, itemized inventory that identifies every carton and uncartoned item, with a number placed on each article. You may observe and verify it, and you get a copy before or at loading.
The booklet says the inventory records the condition of each item and that you have the right to note disagreement. Your ability to recover later may depend on these notations.
375.401(i) lets the estimate be amended by mutual agreement before loading, and never after loading. 375.405(b)(7) and 375.403(a)(6) say what the mover must do when you add goods: reaffirm the estimate or write a new one you sign.
375.505(f) requires both sides to sign before loading and a dated copy to go to you. The estimate and inventory are attachments to the bill of lading under 375.505(b)(15).
375.217(a) and (b) require the form of payment to be specified on both the estimate and the bill of lading, and honored at delivery unless you agree in writing to a change.
375.507 and 375.513 require a non-binding shipment to be weighed on a certified scale and give you the right to observe each weighing. Under 375.515(a), if you choose not to watch a weighing, you are presumed to have waived that right.
At delivery
375.703(b) caps the amount a mover may demand at delivery at 110 percent of the non-binding estimate, plus charges for services you requested after the bill of lading was issued and capped charges for impracticable operations. 375.407 requires the mover to hand over the goods if you pay up to that amount.
375.703(a) limits the demand to the exact estimate plus charges for added services and any impracticable operations. 375.403(a)(7) says that after loading, silence means the original binding estimate stands.
375.407(b) and 375.403(a)(10) treat failing to hand over goods after that offer as failing to transport with reasonable dispatch. The booklet calls it holding the shipment hostage in violation of federal law and gives FMCSA's number for it.
375.701(a) says a delivery receipt must not contain such language. The booklet says to strike it out before signing or refuse delivery if no proper receipt is offered.
375.503(d) requires the mover to let you observe and verify that the same articles are being delivered and their condition, to note missing or damaged items in writing, and to give you a copy of the notations.
375.519(d) requires true copies of all weight tickets with any freight bill that depends on weight. The booklet says if a non-binding invoice does not list each service and its charge, do not accept or pay it.
375.403(a)(8) and 375.405(b)(9) let a mover bill added services after 30 days from delivery. A bill that arrives sooner, or with no signed attachment, is a reason to ask which document supports it.
Warning signs FMCSA lists
These come from FMCSA's own red-flags list. They are signs to slow down and check, not proof that a company is breaking a rule.
FMCSA lists a demand for cash or a large deposit before the move among its red flags. Ask how and when payment is due, and get it written on the estimate.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
FMCSA names a mover or broker that gives no written estimate, or says it will determine the cost after loading, as a red flag.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
FMCSA lists a website with no local address and no registration or insurance information as a warning sign. Look the company up in the Registered Mover Database before you go further.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
FMCSA lists that claim as a red flag. What protects your goods on an interstate move is the valuation option on your paperwork, so ask which one you are getting.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
FMCSA lists a phone answered with "Movers" or "Moving Company", rather than the company's name, as a warning sign.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
FMCSA includes offices and a warehouse in poor condition or nonexistent in its list.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
FMCSA lists a rental truck arriving in place of a company-owned or marked fleet truck as a red flag.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
FMCSA lists this claim as a warning sign. The rules on what a mover must do when the shipment really is larger are in the pickup section above.
Source: FMCSA, Spot the Red Flags
What to do next
Any complaint or claim rests on these papers. Appendix A advises keeping all receipts and supporting documents when a mover asks for cash.
The booklet in Appendix A gives FMCSA's number for a mover that refuses to deliver unless you pay something it is not entitled to charge. FMCSA's consumer page explains how to file a complaint.
Source: FMCSA, Protect Your Move
FMCSA's consumer page and the booklet both say the agency cannot resolve claims against a mover. Arbitration, a civil case or a lawyer are the routes for money disputes.
Source: FMCSA, Protect Your Move
375.211 requires a mover to run an arbitration program for these disputes. You are not required to use it.
Sources (3)
In short: A warning sign is only useful if you know the rule behind it. This list pairs common red flags with the federal requirement for an interstate mover: written estimates, no blank documents, a hard cap at delivery on non-binding estimates, and what to do if it goes wrong.
Most advice about moving scams is a list of hunches: the price seems too low, the company seems pushy. This list works the other way around. Each line states a behavior and then the federal rule that either requires it or forbids it, so you can check what you are seeing against the text instead of against your nerves. It is written for people planning an interstate move, and it describes behavior only. It does not say which companies behave this way, and nothing on this site will.
Which moves the rules cover
The rules cited here are in 49 CFR Part 375, the federal consumer rules for household goods carriers moving belongings across state lines for an individual. Section 375.101 says they apply to a carrier engaged in interstate transportation of household goods. A move that starts and ends in one state is outside Part 375, so if that is your situation, ask your state's consumer protection office what, if anything, applies to local movers there. FMCSA's booklet also notes that a move that crosses a state line inside the same metropolitan commercial zone is outside these rules.
How to use the list
Start with the section for the stage you are at. The first section matters most because everything in it happens before you have committed. If any line applies to you, read the reason under it, then decide what to do: ask for the missing document, ask the company to correct it, or walk away. Items marked urgent are the ones where waiting costs you leverage, such as being pressed to sign a blank page or being told your belongings will stay on the truck until you pay more than the rules allow.
Section numbers in the reasons let you read the original. They are written the way the eCFR prints them, for example 375.401 for estimates and 375.505 for the bill of lading. For the difference between the two kinds of estimate, see binding vs non-binding estimates, and to look a company up first, see looking up a mover's USDOT number.
The fourth section is different in kind. It repeats the warning signs FMCSA publishes on its own red-flags page, such as a phone answered with a generic greeting or a rental truck turning up on moving day. Those are not rule breaches by themselves, so they carry no section number. Treat one of them as a reason to slow down and run the checks in the first section before you sign anything.
Worked example: the delivery-day demand
Say you signed a non-binding estimate with a written total on its face. When the truck arrives, the driver hands you a weighed invoice that is well above that total and says the goods stay on the truck until it is paid in full.
Work through the delivery section. Section 375.703(b) sets the maximum a mover may demand at delivery on a non-binding estimate: 110 percent of the estimate, plus charges for services you asked for after the bill of lading was issued, plus a capped amount for impracticable operations if those apply. Section 375.407 says that if you pay up to that amount, the mover must hand over the shipment. The estimate itself was also required to say, on its face, that you will not be required to pay more than that limit at delivery (375.405(b)(5)). Whatever sits above the limit can be billed to you afterward, and the booklet says the mover bills the remaining charges after 30 days from delivery. You still owe the legitimate balance. You do not owe it before your furniture comes off the truck.
So the move is: calculate 110 percent of your written estimate, add any extras you signed for, and offer that amount in the payment form the paperwork names. If the mover still refuses to unload, write down the time and the driver's words, and call the number in FMCSA's booklet for exactly this situation. Do not argue about it in a driveway for hours. The record you keep matters more.
What changes the answer
Some situations look like red flags but are not. A mover may legally require you to sign a document that has not been completed, but only where the missing information cannot be known before loading, such as the actual weight on a non-binding move (375.505(g)(2)). A mover may also bill for unforeseen services after delivery. A volume-based estimate can be converted to a weight-based rate if the mover gave you the formula in writing (375.401(e)). And if you add items on moving day, the estimate can change before loading, but only with your agreement.
When to call a professional or an agency
FMCSA runs the consumer page and complaint process, and its page says plainly that it cannot resolve claims against a mover. For a damage or loss dispute, the paths are the mover's claims process, the arbitration program the mover must offer, or a lawyer. The damage claim letter helps you put a claim in writing. If the mover is holding your goods and the amount demanded is above what the rules allow, contact FMCSA at the number in the booklet immediately and consider speaking to a lawyer about the cost of delay. This page is information about rules, not legal advice.
Questions people ask
Is a deposit a red flag by itself?
Part 375 does not set a rule on deposits, so a deposit on its own is not a violation of it. What the regulation does say is that the form of payment must be written on the estimate and the bill of lading and honored at delivery. Ask for the payment terms in writing before you pay anything.
What if the company gave me a link instead of the booklet?
That is allowed. Section 375.213(f) says that if you agree to get the federal information through a link, the mover must obtain a signed, dated receipt that records your agreement. Read the booklet anyway.
Can I cancel after signing the bill of lading?
Section 375.505(h) requires the bill of lading to be signed at least 3 days before the scheduled loading and gives you a 3-day period after signing to rescind it without penalty.